|
Post by The Quito Diet on Nov 16, 2014 16:44:36 GMT
As per previous mafia games everything I've said has been true rofl, I just genuinely don't get them past the basics.
|
|
Бенне
Key Player
Posts: 8,749
Likes: 1,800
Team: Nottingham Forest
|
Post by Бенне on Nov 16, 2014 16:53:35 GMT
As per previous mafia games everything I've said has been true rofl, I just genuinely don't get them past the basics. It's the delay in confirming you were a PGO that got me hahaha. I'm amazed.
|
|
|
Post by localnative on Nov 18, 2014 19:20:07 GMT
Kuhn when you doing your post game write up?
|
|
Kuhn
Regular
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 69
|
Post by Kuhn on Nov 18, 2014 23:53:58 GMT
I won't pull another video games mafia I swear
Just been busy with school and applications and shit. I'll start em up soon.
|
|
|
Post by Memento Mori on Nov 26, 2014 18:42:08 GMT
Do we have an ETA on this, Kuhn?
|
|
Kuhn
Regular
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 69
|
Post by Kuhn on Nov 27, 2014 19:02:28 GMT
If I don't start this weekend I'll kill myself
|
|
Бенне
Key Player
Posts: 8,749
Likes: 1,800
Team: Nottingham Forest
|
Post by Бенне on Nov 27, 2014 20:53:38 GMT
I'd advise starting this weekend given that choice mate.
|
|
|
Post by The Quito Diet on Nov 30, 2014 17:58:35 GMT
Kuhn I'm beginning to get worried pal
|
|
|
Post by Memento Mori on Dec 1, 2014 7:02:04 GMT
|
|
Kuhn
Regular
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 69
|
Post by Kuhn on Dec 1, 2014 23:08:11 GMT
What? Who died? 1 - Poor 2 - Mediocre 3 - Average 4 - Good 5 - Great pls don't take anything personally. Just my own opinions on how people played, with a mix of activity, what was done with that activity, combination of cards chosen out of the possibilities and use of ability (if applicable). Also, don't go comparing scores between people, because not everybody will be rated based on the same criteria. Hellas - Town Cop FBI Agent Judas Werewolf Cop Hellas chose town instead of Werewolf or Judas (which I thought would've been really interesting; Judas is town but converts to mafia when lynched instead of dying, so as a Judas Cop, he could've potentially found his mafia partners and took the hit for them, thus converting him to their side and helping them immensely). Town Cop was a good choice though, even though there were only two mafia in the game and one was taken out right away. Better than taking FBI Agent at least, because there weren't even any SKs ( three people turned down the opportunity!), and absolutely better than just being Vanilla Werewolf or Town. Good choice of ability, in my opinion, though I have literally no input on how well he would've used it because he was killed before he could even post. He got a post in before I declared him dead, which was a logical thought process (looking into those who discarded town cards), though that's not the safest route because mafia could always have two mafia cards, or a mafia card and a werewolf card, or a townie could have had three town cards, etc. It's absolutely a good way to start on D1 when nothing is known, though. As I can't judge him based on play style (he practically did not get to play), nor ability usage, all I've got his what he chose and what he attempted to do before being daykilled, so... Rating - 5 - Though I personally thought Judas would have been cooler (because the concept is really interesting to me), Town Cop was a great choice, and his only post in the game gave a pretty logical way to start off a blind Day 1.
localnative - Mafia Gravedigger Gravedigger Mason Mafia Godfather localnative only had four possible role choices, due to a duplicate and a banned role (Mafia Mason), and one of those was essentially useless (Town Godfather). He couldn't pick Mafia Godfather, but wanted to be Mafia, so his only option was Mafia Gravedigger, which could either work out really well or really poorly. I think Town Gravedigger would have been a pretty poor choice because all it would serve to do is screw with results, and as a townie you don't need to give town any extra trouble to work through. I personally would have picked Town Mason, as being in a mason is great fun and very useful to town, but there wasn't even one this game, so he essentially would have been vanilla. Anyway, I can't say for sure how he would have played the Gravedigger role since he didn't really get a chance to claim or anything, but from what he told me, it would have been a smart one (if he came up on any results he could've claimed Gravedigger, could've proved it the next night phase, etc.--not a foolproof plan but probably the best way to play the role). He spent his only day phase in the game trying to bring heat to a few townies (in his eyes they were just people that weren't under his alignment and, therefore, he most likely needed dead) by questioning them about their discards, specifically notpropaganda, who I think he did a good job against. Probably set suspicion on him from a few players until he died because of that discard alone. With only two mafia, he made a smart play by telling mnolan to distant themselves in-thread as much as possible and not come to each other's defense, due to the various possible threats and the fact that there were only two of them from the start. I thought that was a brilliant idea, though I never really got to see it come into effect because local died Night 1. Rating - 5 - Pretty active while he was alive, and he did a great job with trying to put attention on those that he needed dead. Chose an interesting card combination that could be difficult to pull off but he seemed to know how he was going to go about it. Unfortunately, he was never given that opportunity.
DIOS - Werewolf Godfather Werewolf Miller Werewolf Godfather Mafia Goon DIOS literally had to be scum, lol. Either Werewolf or Mafia, but he had to be scum. Honestly, though, I thought his choice was one of the worst ones he could have made. He said he wanted to discard Mafia Goon to make himself look better, but in the process he made himself a vanilla Werewolf basically. Best route he could've taken was Mafia Godfather, making him immune to investigations and actually giving him a role in the game rather than just a vanilla Werewolf, while still having discarded a scum card and making himself look good to everyone. He was smart in the Werewolf chat with the plays he suggested, such as taking the factional kill as to prevent a roleblock from ruining all the kills that night (as Benneh was the Werewolf Vig), but he didn't do too much in-thread while he was alive. He wasn't inactive, but he chose to try staying under the radar from the look of things. Rating - 3 - Though he wasn't inactive, he didn't really do too much in the thread while he was alive (he didn't seem scummy, but in a game with so many harmful groups (potentially), and a game full of reads without write-ups, being on the quieter side doesn't do you a favor. I really thought his card combinations were bad, given what he could have chosen instead, and it's not like he only wanted to be scum, because he could have been scum either way. With the Mafia Godfather, though, he would've set himself up much better.
|
|
Stu
Talisman
#SparkysOnFire
Posts: 16,092
Likes: 4,599
Team: Southampton
|
Post by Stu on Dec 1, 2014 23:18:14 GMT
hellas was defo motm imo
|
|
|
Post by Memento Mori on Dec 7, 2014 17:36:51 GMT
|
|
Kuhn
Regular
Posts: 1,066
Likes: 69
|
Post by Kuhn on Dec 7, 2014 19:55:07 GMT
Yeah, uh
Alright I think this is how I'll do it. If you'd like me to give you one just post here saying you want it and when I do them next I'll do the people that actually want one
Unless you all want one but that doesn't seem to be the case haha
|
|
|
Post by The Quito Diet on Dec 7, 2014 19:58:00 GMT
Think most would appreciate it tbh but obviously it's a big ask.
I'll take one.
|
|
|
Post by localnative on Dec 7, 2014 20:01:18 GMT
Can you redo mine. There's no way I didn't get more than Hellas!
|
|